Black Cherry Old Fashioned with Collins Stemmed Black Cherries
A bold, cherry-forward twist on the classic Old Fashioned that uses Collins Stemmed Black Cherries both muddled and as a garnish. Rich bourbon, a touch of jar syrup and Angostura bitters create a smooth, balanced cocktail for fans of whiskey and fruit-forward twists.
Ingredient Spotlight
Collins Stemmed Black Cherries
Stemmed black cherries are preserved cocktail cherries—darker, firmer, and less saccharine than the bright red maraschino cherries many home cooks know. They’re sold in jars in cocktail or specialty food sections and are commonly used as garnishes for drinks like an Old Fashioned. A good substitute is a jarred Luxardo or amarena cherry, or high-quality maraschino cherries drained and patted dry.
(paid link) — as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Ingredient Spotlight
Angostura bitters
Angostura bitters are a concentrated aromatic bitter produced by the House of Angostura (Trinidad) used in cocktails and savory cooking to add bitter, spicy, and herbal complexity. Flavor notes include bitter citrus, clove, cinnamon, and other botanicals; only a few dashes are needed. Find it at liquor stores or well-stocked groceries; substitutes include other aromatic cocktail bitters (e.g., Peychaud’s) or a small pinch of ground allspice/cinnamon plus a splash of bitter liqueur if necessary.
(paid link) — as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Ingredient Spotlight
Demerara sugar
Demerara is a minimally refined cane sugar with large golden-brown crystals and a pronounced molasses-toffee flavor derived from the Demerara region name (Guyana). It’s used where a crunchy texture or deeper caramel notes are desired, such as in cocktails, baking, and toppings. Available in grocery baking aisles and specialty stores; substitutes are turbinado sugar or a mix of granulated sugar with a little molasses or light brown sugar.
Jake's note
"This recipe highlights Collins Stemmed Black Cherries to give a deep, jammy cherry flavor without overpowering the whiskey—perfect for relaxed evenings or dinner parties where you want a familiar cocktail with a fruity flourish."
Black Cherry Old Fashioned with Collins Stemmed Black Cherries
This Black Cherry Old Fashioned takes the familiar, comforting frame of a classic Old Fashioned and introduces a deliberate, fruit-forward personality without turning the drink into a cloying tiki-style sweet. Using Collins Stemmed Black Cherries both as a muddled base and as a garnish gives the cocktail depth — the jar syrup lends glossy body and immediate sweetness, while the fruit flesh delivers concentrated jammy notes and a slow, tannic cherry bitterness that plays beautifully with oak and vanilla in bourbon. Demerara sugar and Angostura bitters keep the structure grounded: the sugar melts into a warm molasses backbone and the bitters add aromatics and spice, so the cherry never overwhelms the whiskey's core character.
Keep the technique simple but intentional. Gentle muddling releases juices and color without pulverizing pits or shredding fibers that make the drink gritty; double-straining over one large ice cube preserves silkiness and controlled dilution. Expressing an orange peel over the glass brightens the dark fruit and lifts the nose with citrus oil, so each sip feels layered rather than one-note. This version is for people who love whiskey-first cocktails with a decisive fruit accent — it works as an evening sipper, a winter-leaning aperitif, or a digestif companion to chocolate or aged cheese.
Plan your timing
Ingredients
Instructions
Muddle cherries with syrup, sugar and bitters
For this step
- 6 piecesCollins Stemmed Black Cherries
- 1 tbspCherry syrup (from jar)
- 6 dashesAngostura bitters
- 0.5 tspDemerara sugar
Add bourbon and ice, then stir
For this step
- 4 fl ozBourbon
- 4 piecesLarge ice cubes
Strain over fresh ice
Express and garnish
For this step
- 2 twistsOrange peel
Tips from the kitchen
Muddle Gently
Press the cherries to release juices rather than pulverizing; use a few gentle twists so you avoid bitter pit fragments and fibrous texture.
Use Jar Syrup Wisely
The syrup is flavorful and viscous—start with the tablespoon called for and adjust in future pours rather than adding more initially to avoid over-sweetening.
Choose Big Ice
One large ice cube chills with minimal dilution; it preserves aroma and keeps the drink silky longer than multiple small cubes.
Double-Strain For Smoothness
Use a Hawthorne strainer plus a fine mesh to remove pulp for a clean mouthfeel while retaining all the cherry flavor.
Express Citrus Oils
When you twist the orange peel, hold it close to the glass and give a sharp snap to spray oils onto the surface for immediate aromatic lift.
Variations & substitutions
Bitter Cherry Twist
Swap half the demerara for a barspoon of Luxardo Maraschino liqueur and reduce jar syrup to 1/2 teaspoon to introduce floral, slightly bitter cherry depth.
Rye Substitute
Use rye whiskey (4 oz total) for a spicier backbone that contrasts the cherry’s sweetness with peppery notes and a drier finish.
Smoked Old Fashioned
Briefly smoke the mixing glass with a handheld smoker before adding ingredients or use a smoked salt rim for an autumnal, savory edge.
Low-ABV Version
Replace half the bourbon with chilled black cherry tea or a low-ABV cherry shrub and keep the bitters and syrup proportions the same for a lighter option.
Storage & make-ahead
If you have leftover muddled cherries, store them in an airtight container in the fridge and use within 48–72 hours; their texture will continue to break down but they make a great topping for ice cream or yogurt. The jar syrup keeps indefinitely sealed, and once opened refrigerate it—use the syrup in vinaigrettes or cocktails. For make-ahead entertaining, pre-batch the muddled cherry and bourbon mixture (without ice) in a sealed pitcher and refrigerate up to 24 hours, then stir with fresh ice and double-strain just before serving.
What to serve with it
Serve these Old Fashioneds in heavy rocks glasses with one large ice cube and a short metal cocktail pick for the cherry; chilled coupe glass is also elegant if you prefer no ice. Pair with savory snacks that echo the cocktail’s richness—smoked almonds, aged Gouda, or a charcuterie board with cured meats and dark fruit preserves—while desserts like bittersweet chocolate or cherry clafoutis make a harmonious finish. Keep water nearby; the cocktail’s intensity benefits from a sip of plain water between sips.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use fresh cherries instead of jarred ones?
Yes—pitted fresh black cherries work well, but you’ll want to add a teaspoon of simple syrup to compensate for the missing jar syrup and expect a slightly brighter, less jammy flavor.
What bourbon works best here?
Choose a mid-proof bourbon (90–100 proof) with caramel, vanilla and toasted oak notes; higher-rye bourbons add spice while sweeter, lower-rye Bourbons emphasize the cherry’s richness.
How sweet will this drink be, and can I reduce sugar?
This recipe is balanced toward whiskey-forward with a clear cherry-sweetness; reduce the demerara to 1/4 teaspoon or cut jar syrup to 1/2 tablespoon if you prefer drier cocktails.
Why double-strain the cocktail?
Double-straining removes tiny solids and pulp from the muddled cherries, producing a velvety texture and preventing gritty bits from lingering on the palate.
Can I batch this for a party?
Yes—multiply the recipe and combine muddled cherries, syrup and bourbon in a sealed pitcher up to 24 hours ahead; keep it refrigerated and stir with ice then double-strain into glasses when serving.
About the author
JakeHello, I'm Jake. I started this recipe site with the idea that I hated recipe websites that overwhelm you with long stories and ads just to see plain content that's not helpful. My goal is to provide you with quality recipes, simple ideas and a fun cooking experience. There's lots of fun things to cook, and I think as you browse the site you'll find that TopShelf.Recipes is the place for quality recipes on the web.
See all recipes by Jake →Ratings & Reviews
Did you make this recipe?
Be the first to share your experience.
Ingredients
- Bourbon4 fl oz
- Large ice cubes4 pieces
- Orange peel2 twists
🛒 = paid link — as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition Facts
Per serving: 1 cocktail (320g)
Nutrition values are estimated from USDA ingredient data and may vary based on preparation, brands, and portion sizes. Values are provided for informational purposes only.
Keep Reading
Guides & articles for this recipe
Guides
Trending Grillside Drinks for 2026: Cocktails, Low‑ABV Sippers, and Non‑Alcoholic Pairings to Elevate Backyard BBQ
Discover the hottest drinks to serve alongside summer grilling in 2026 — from smoked‑syrup cocktails and barrel‑aged RTDs to low‑ABV spritzes, shrubs, kombuchas, and tea blends. Includes batch-making tips, safety notes, and pairing suggestions for common grilled proteins and sides.
Recipes
Blue Drinks at Home: Natural Color Techniques + 10 Viral Blue Cocktail & Mocktail Recipes
Discover how to make stunning blue drinks at home using natural ingredients like butterfly pea and blue spirulina. This guide includes practical techniques, storage tips, and 10 viral cocktail and mocktail recipes — many with grilled-garnish ideas for backyard entertaining.
Tips & Techniques
Seasonal Flavor Framework
A practical guide to composing balanced late-summer plates by pairing charred proteins, smoky accents, bright quick pickles, fresh herbs, and crunchy textures. Includes short technique boxes (quick pickles, finishing oils, compound butters) and clear timing notes so readers can mix-and-match market produce into satisfying meals.
More from Drinks
View all Drinks recipes →Grilled-Fig Gin Slushy with Honey-Thyme Syrup
Campfire-Smoked Old Fashioned with Grilled Cherry‑Balsamic Syrup
Maple Bourbon Sour
Espresso Whiskey Martini
Smoked Old Fashioned
Spicy Cadillac Margarita
Skinny Cadillac Margarita
Brown Sugar Syrup Cold Brew Latte
Dirty Chai Latte
Ask me anything about this recipe — substitutions, scaling, techniques, timing.
Powered by AI · Answers may not always be perfect